So call me old-fashioned, but I don’t think a BBQ picnic is complete without baked beans. And not the kind of baked beans containing fancy new ingredients like quinoa, agave nectar, or stevia. I’m talking about the kind of baked beans I’ve been preparing since my early 20s. Dry beans rehydrated with lots of ketchup, brown sugar, bacon, onion, rum, Dijon mustard, etc. (OK, I didn’t use rum or Dijon mustard when I first started making baked beans. But a few concessions for the sake of flavor simply had to be made as I developed as a cook. And I’m sure my father, the baked bean maker in our family would agree with each of my respective inclusions.)

So, because I consider myself to be am open minded person, and my daughter Paula just happened to have gifted me with an Instant Pot a couple of Christmas’s ago, I decided to make this recipe for baked beans a generational mash up.

First and foremost, baked beans have to be made from scratch. (And yes I have cheated over the years and purchased a big old can of baked beans and doctored them up to my liking. But in my defense, that was when I was much younger, still working, and had kidlets littered about the house. However, now that I am retired with virtually nothing stopping me from spending hours in the kitchen, I no longer go that route.)

Anyway, this recipe contains all of the ingredients I used when I began preparing baked beans decades ago, except for of course the aforementioned rum and Dijon mustard.

So if you too love baked beans, give this recipe a try. And yes it still takes a good deal of time to bake beans from scratch. But most of the time you are free to pursue other activities. Very little prep time is involved. The rest of the time your Instant Pot and oven are doing the heavy work.   

So host a picnic before the summer is over. There is just no better way to spend quality time with your family and friends than by getting your faces totally smeared with BBQ sauce, or having your arms and elbows become sodden from the juices dripping out of a luscious hamburger. Good times my friends. Good times!

And for a recipe for Vegetarian Baked Beans – check out the recipe already on this site.

2 lbs. Great Northern beans, picked over and washed (about 4½ cups dry beans)

8 c. water, plus more as needed

1 lg. yellow onion, chopped, divided

2 tsp. paprika

3 garlic cloves, chopped

2 bay leaves

¾ lb. lean thick-cut bacon, cut into small pieces

2/3 c. molasses (not blackstrap – too strong)

2 c. ketchup, or more to taste

½ dark rum, opt.

2 T. Worcestershire sauce

2 T. dried parsley

½ tsp. dried thyme leaves

½ tsp. dried savory

1-2 tsp. seasoned salt

freshly ground black pepper

¼ c. Dijon mustard

1½ c. brown sugar

Place half of the beans, water, half of the chopped onion, paprika, garlic, and bay leaves in the Instant Pot. Note the water level for future reference. Set on high and cook for 35 minutes. (See guide below if not using Great Northern dry beans.) Once machine is done cooking, allow it to naturally release pressure for about 20 minutes. Manually release the remaining pressure and carefully remove the lid. Using a large slotted spoon, lift the beans into a container. Save the water.

Add the remaining half of the dry beans and enough water to bring the level in the pot up to where it was for the first set of beans.

Please note: If you have a large Instant Pot, you may be able to pressure cook all the dry beans at once. If so, lucky you! I only have a 6 quart pot so I had to cook the beans in 2 batches.

While the beans are cooking, fry the bacon in a large fry-pan until crisp. Add the remaining onion and sauté just until translucent. (And no, you don’t drain off the bacon fat unless there is quite a bit. But with lean bacon you shouldn’t have too much.) Remove pan from heat and stir in the molasses, ketchup, rum, Worcestershire sauce, parsley, thyme, savory, salt, pepper, Dijon mustard, and brown sugar.

When the beans are all cooked, drain off all the water. (Save a couple cups of the water just in case additional liquid is needed during the baking process.) After the beans are drained, add them to the fry pan. Taste the sauce and adjust seasoning as required.

Pour into an oven proof covered casserole. Cover and bake in a pre-heated 275 degree oven for about 2 hours. Remove the lid and continue baking for another hour so that the top can brown nicely. (During the baking time, check the beans periodically to make sure they aren’t drying out too much. Add reserved Instant Pot water as needed.)

Remove from oven and serve warm.

Can be made ahead, refrigerated, and warmed just before serving.  

Instant Pot Cooking Time for Dried Beans:

Black Beans–30 Minutes on High Pressure

Chickpeas–40 Minutes on High Pressure

Kidney Beans–35 Minutes on High Pressure

Pinto Beans–25 Minutes on High Pressure

Navy Beans–30 Minutes on High Pressure